ALOT
AstroNova, Inc.
TL;DR
Sum-of-the-parts value obscured by PI drag; new management offers credible path to unlock Aerospace's strength.
AstroNova is a tale of two segments: a robust Aerospace business generating high-margin recurring revenue, dragged down by a troubled Product Identification unit facing customer attrition and operational woes. Activist pressure has installed a new CEO from competitor Zebra Technologies, setting the stage for a potential turnaround, but recent earnings misses and guidance cuts highlight the risks ahead.
Investment Outlook
NeutralAsymmetric Trade Idea
vs. spot on Sep 28, 2025
days
6/10
Q3 earnings in December 2025 demonstrate initial PI retention under new CEO, combined with Aerospace transition progress, triggering multiple expansion from depressed 6x EV/EBITDA.
Investment Thesis
AstroNova represents a classic 'good company/bad company' setup where the high-quality Aerospace segment's value is undervalued due to the PI segment's mismanagement, with activist-driven leadership changes providing a catalyst for separation or recovery.
AstroNova has long been hampered by the PI segment's issues, including a failed acquisition and ink quality problems leading to customer loss. The Aerospace division, however, thrives on exclusive licenses and standard equipment status with Boeing and Airbus, delivering 45% recurring revenue. The Askeladden Capital campaign forced board and CEO changes, importing expertise from Zebra to fix PI. With Q2 FY2026 results showing declines but a 'kitchen sink' guidance reset, now is the moment to bet on execution under new leadership.
Investment Debates
PI Segment Turnaround
CRITICALPI revenue fell 8.9% YoY to $24.8M in Q2 FY2026, with $2.6M drop in recurring supplies; new CEO from Zebra brings direct expertise.
Bull
Recoverable with expertise
Jorik Ittmann's Zebra background enables quick customer retention and margin restoration, potentially returning PI to 10%+ operating margins as seen in Q1.
Bear
Permanent customer loss
Ink quality issues caused irreversible attrition in high-margin consumables, dooming PI to continued low-teens revenue and sub-8% margins.
PI Segment Turnaround
CRITICALPI revenue fell 8.9% YoY to $24.8M in Q2 FY2026, with $2.6M drop in recurring supplies; new CEO from Zebra brings direct expertise.
Bull
Recoverable with expertise
Jorik Ittmann's Zebra background enables quick customer retention and margin restoration, potentially returning PI to 10%+ operating margins as seen in Q1.
Bear
Permanent customer loss
Ink quality issues caused irreversible attrition in high-margin consumables, dooming PI to continued low-teens revenue and sub-8% margins.
Aerospace Growth Sustainability
HIGHAerospace revenue $11.3M in Q2, down 15.1% due to OEM shipment timing; 50% complete transition to higher-margin ToughWriter printers, targeting 80% by FY end.
Bull
Tailwinds accelerate adoption
Honeywell license and Airbus standard status ensure steady aftermarket growth, with printer upgrades driving 20%+ YoY revenue by FY2027.
Bear
Lumpy OEM dependence
Shipment volatility and certification barriers limit upside, capping Aerospace at flat revenue and eroding margins below 20%.
Aerospace Growth Sustainability
HIGHAerospace revenue $11.3M in Q2, down 15.1% due to OEM shipment timing; 50% complete transition to higher-margin ToughWriter printers, targeting 80% by FY end.
Bull
Tailwinds accelerate adoption
Honeywell license and Airbus standard status ensure steady aftermarket growth, with printer upgrades driving 20%+ YoY revenue by FY2027.
Bear
Lumpy OEM dependence
Shipment volatility and certification barriers limit upside, capping Aerospace at flat revenue and eroding margins below 20%.
Activist Influence Effectiveness
HIGHAskeladden campaign led to new CEO and board changes; Q2 guidance cut to $149-154M revenue, 7.5-8.5% EBITDA margin.
Bull
Strategic reset succeeds
New leadership's 'kitchen sink' approach sets low bar for beats, with inventory turns improving to 3.0x freeing cash for PI fixes.
Bear
Too late for recovery
Structural PI damage and covenant risks persist, leading to further impairments like the $13.4M MTEX hit in Q4 FY2025.
Activist Influence Effectiveness
HIGHAskeladden campaign led to new CEO and board changes; Q2 guidance cut to $149-154M revenue, 7.5-8.5% EBITDA margin.
Bull
Strategic reset succeeds
New leadership's 'kitchen sink' approach sets low bar for beats, with inventory turns improving to 3.0x freeing cash for PI fixes.
Bear
Too late for recovery
Structural PI damage and covenant risks persist, leading to further impairments like the $13.4M MTEX hit in Q4 FY2025.
Recurring Revenue Stability
MEDIUM70% of revenue recurring company-wide, but PI supplies down; Aerospace 45% aftermarket.
Bull
Razor-blade model intact
Aerospace's entrenched position in 737/A320 fleets ensures predictable cash flow to fund turnaround.
Bear
Eroding annuity stream
PI attrition signals broader loyalty issues, threatening overall 70% recurring base.
Recurring Revenue Stability
MEDIUM70% of revenue recurring company-wide, but PI supplies down; Aerospace 45% aftermarket.
Bull
Razor-blade model intact
Aerospace's entrenched position in 737/A320 fleets ensures predictable cash flow to fund turnaround.
Bear
Eroding annuity stream
PI attrition signals broader loyalty issues, threatening overall 70% recurring base.
Company Overview
Operations
AstroNova operates two segments: Product Identification (PI) for coding/marking printers and supplies (65% revenue), and Aerospace & Test (35%) for flight deck electronics like ToughWriter printers and DAQ instruments, generating high-margin aftermarket revenue.
Market Position
Dominant in narrow-body aircraft printers via Honeywell license and Airbus OEM status; PI competes with Zebra in fragmented market but lost ground due to quality issues; TAM in aerospace aftermarket is stable with high barriers.
Recent Events
Q2 FY2026 earnings on Sept 9, 2025 showed 10.9% revenue decline to $36.1M and net loss of $1.2M; guidance cut to $149-154M FY revenue; new CEO Jorik Ittmann started Aug 15, 2025.
Governance & Forensics
Management Alignment
New CEO Jorik Ittmann from Zebra aligns incentives with 70% bonus tied to profitability; activist board influence enhances shareholder focus, but prior mismanagement evident in MTEX failure.
Capital Allocation History
Past errors include covenant-breaching MTEX acquisition and $13.4M impairment; recent debt paydown of $3.7M shows stabilization, with $3.9M cash and compliance maintaining liquidity.
Key Catalysts
December 2025
Q3 Earnings Beat
Early signs of PI stabilization under new CEO could drive re-rating; watch customer retention metrics.
Q4 FY2026 (April 2026)
Printer Transition Completion
80% upgrade to ToughWriter for major OEM unlocks higher margins in Aerospace.
H1 FY2027
Inventory Optimization
Achieving 3.0x turns frees working capital, improving cash flow and balance sheet.
Mid-2026
Potential Segment Separation
Activist push for sum-of-the-parts unlock via spin-off of Aerospace.
Valuation Scenarios
Sum-of-the-parts: Value Aerospace at 15-20x EBITDA for its moats, discount PI at 5-8x until turnaround proves; consolidated at 8-10x FY2026 EBITDA midpoint of $11.5-13M.
$10-12/share
$15-18/share
$22-25/share
$35/share (5-year horizon)
Risk Factors
PI Customer Attrition Persists
Further revenue erosion to below $140M FY2026, pressuring EBITDA below 7% and risking covenants.
Aerospace Shipment Delays
Lumpy OEM volumes cause quarterly misses, amplifying PI weakness and eroding investor confidence.
Execution Failure by New CEO
If Zebra expertise doesn't translate, prolonged losses lead to activist escalation or sale at discount.
Regulatory/Certification Hurdles
FAA/EASA delays slow printer upgrades, capping Aerospace growth and recurring revenue.
Conclusion
AstroNova's Aerospace gem is buried under PI rubble, but new leadership and activist oversight offer a realistic shot at unearthing value through recovery or separation. Base case stabilization tempers enthusiasm, but asymmetry favors patient bulls.
Hypothetical Position
Long ALOT shares with a 12-18 month horizon, sizing 2-3% of portfolio, stops below $10 on covenant breach.
Informational only. Not financial advice. Content reflects community and AI-aggregated opinions, not personalized recommendations. Investing involves risk; do your own research. Price targets and projections are hypothetical and not guarantees. User submissions and history are provided “as is” and are not verified.
Related stocks
Supported: Gemini, ChatGPT. (Claude and Grok coming soon)